Everton have had a strange season. They'd been under pressure to spend money during the transfer window in the summer, and the £15 million fee for Maroune Fellaini on deadline day looked a bit of a panic buy. It also didn't make that much sense in terms of how well he'd fit into Everton's system - in Tim Cahill they already had one midfielder who is an impact player, most effective arriving in the box to get on the end of crosses, rather than creating further back in midfield. Fellaini is similar to this.
They tried to play both Cahill and Fellaini in the middle, but this meant that the other central midfield space had to be taken up by a more defensive player like Neville or Castillo while Cahill and Fellaini made their forward runs. This meant that there was no room for Mikel Arteta in the centre of the park, so he was shunted out to the wing, where his influence on matches diminished.
They usually played 4-5-1 with Yakubu up front and it didn't work particularly well, with Everton around mid-table at the end of November. It was at this stage that Yakubu picked up a serious Achilles injury that ruled him out for the rest of the season. Many thought that this would be a disaster for Everton's campaign, as their only other available strikers were the injury-ravaged Saha and unprolific Anichebe. For their next match they essentially played a 4-6-0 formation, Castillo, Arteta, Fellaini and Cahill all operating in the centre of midfield, with Fellaini and Cahill pushing on to act as strikers when Everton were attacking.
This enabled Arteta to pull the strings in the centre of midfield, and the goals were still coming, mainly from set pieces and Cahill or Fellaini headers. Everton's superb defence and solid set-up meant they went on a run five wins out of six following Yakubu's injury, despite the ridiculousness of the concept of a 4-6-0 formation. Their good form continued, but I worried for them when they signed Manchester City misfit Jo on loan in the January transfer window. I'd seen him play a few times for Man City, and it'd be fair to say he was short on effectiveness as well as letters. He'd done absolutely nothing in any of the games I'd seen him play in, and looked lethargic and disinterested.
I was starting to think that at £19 million and presumably a very large wage he was possibly the biggest waste of money in football of all time. It was difficult to imagine how he could improve Everton. I was more inclined to expect them to get worse, given that the successful 4-6-0 they'd stumbled across would presumably revert to 4-5-1 with Jo up top. However, it looked like I might be proved wrong when Jo played really well on his debut in a 3-0 win against Bolton, scoring two goals.
This may seem like an elaborate and unnecessary ramble on Everton's tactics this season, and perhaps it is, but this was all going through my head when Mikel Arteta was stretchered off with an injured knee a few minutes into the game against Newcastle. Osman, Pienaar, Fellaini and Cahill were all missing the game through injury or suspension, so this meant that Everton were without an entire first choice midfield.
I'd thought that Everton should have been slight favourites before Arteta went off, but he's had such an impact on the fortunes of Everton this year that I thought the game should have been about equal, or Newcastle slight favourites after he went off. All the spread betting bookmakers moved the prices towards Newcastle after the injury, but one bookmaker were still quoting 0.05-0.25 Everton on supremacy. It's subjective how much an individual player affects a team's performance, but I thought they hadn't moved it enough, so had a small SELL OF EVERTON SUPREMACY AT 0.05.
My bet was looking good as Everton were lacking creativity in midfield for the rest of the half while Newcastle had one or two chances, but it all went wrong when Newcastle's Kevin Nolan was sent off for a horror tackle on Victor Anichebe. Going down to 10 men meant that Everton would definitely have to be big favourites in the second half, but I was still hopeful that the lack of guile in the midfield of Rodwell, Gosling, Neville, Castillo and Fellaini (he'd come on as a sub at half time) would make it tricky for them to score. And so it proved, as despite some Everton pressure in the second half, Jo was unable to find the net and the game petered out to a 0-0 draw, giving me a small winner on the supremacy bet.
AR